YMCA Camp Sherwin
YMCA Camp Sherwin is a certified child care center in Lake City, PA, with capacity for 62 children. It holds a Keystone STAR 4 rating. Since August 2021, Pennsylvania certification staff have inspected it 6 times and confirmed violations in 1 complaint investigation. The state cited 50 violations, 9 of them core-safety (supervision, staff ratios, discipline, background checks, child protection or safe sleep), most often for building & playground safety (17 of 50). 11 citations came in the last 12 months, including 3 on a core-safety topic. Measured by topic-weighted citations per inspection, it is tied for #48 of 81 centers in Erie County and has more citations per inspection than 87% of Pennsylvania certified centers.
Inspection record
Every state visit
What inspectors cited most
Citations, newest first
Staff person #1 restrained Child #1 using their hands to restrict Child #1's movements. This was confirmed by video footage provided by the legal entity.
Staff persons #5, qualified as an aide, and staff person #1 were observed caring for a group of 16 children including 13 preschool aged children and 3 school aged children. Staff person #1 has not completed the following pre- service training required prior to caring for children unsupervised: Health & Safety Training Topics. Staff person #1 was observed to be caring for children and not supervised by at a minimum an AGS who has completed all preservice trainings and has all qualifications to care for children unsupervised.
Staff persons #5 and #1 were observed caring for a group of 16 children including 13 preschool aged children and 3 school aged children. Staff person #5 is qualified as an aide and staff person #1 has not yet completed preservice trainings so cannot work unsupervised and is therefore not qualified to supervise an aide.
Observed disinfectant spray labeled 'keep out of reach of children' accessible to children in an unlocked closet in the bathroom in the Darone building.
Observed in the Darone building by the lunch tables an open trash can without a lid. In the trash can were plates, cups and napkins from lunch that were contaminated by human secretions.
Observed in the Learning Lodge an approximately 2-inch sized hole in the blue wall near the corner of the shelf. Observed on the playground peeling paint and splintering wood on the side of the storage shed and on the playground side of the Darone building. Observed in the outdoor girl's bathroom black dirt or mold behind the toilets and spider webs around the floor corners and ceiling.
The bathroom in the Darone building and the outdoor girl's bathroom have trash containers that are lacking lids.
Observed in the Learning Lodge a bin of magna-tiles with chipped plastic corners exposing the interior magnets.
Observed on the playground a picnic table top with a protruding bolt.
The files for staff persons #3 and #4 contain current fire safety training that was completed greater than 12 months after the previous fire safety training as evidenced by trainings dated 5/31/2025 and 6/1/2026
The file for staff person #2 is lacking 2 written non-family reference letters.
Show 39 older citations
The file for staff person #2 contains current NSOR verification that was received after the previous NSOR verification was expired evidenced by the dates of the NSOR verifications in the file are dated 11/19/2019 and 5/2/2025.
Observed in the Darone child care space several plants on shelves accessible to children. Included were Peace Lilies, Dieffenbachia sequine and pothos, all toxic to humans.
Observed the restrooms by the camp playground were lacking handwashing signs by each toilet and sink,
The file for staff person #1 contains current PFA/PCPR certification that was completed after the previous certification was expired as evidenced by the certifications on file dated 12/2/2022 and 3/12/2025.
The file for staff person #3 lacked documentation of NSOR clearance results within 45 days of hire (See LIS Code Sheet).
The file for staff person #1, who was hired provisionally, had NSOR clearance results dated 5/9/24 that was after their date of hire (See LIS Code Sheet). Staff person #4, the Director of the facility, was hired provisionally. The file for staff person #4 had NSOR clearance results dated 9/26/23 that was after their date of hire (See LIS Code Sheet).
The file for child #1, who is a preschool child, did not include documentation of a health report conducted within the last 12 months. The most recent documentation on file for is dated 3/28/23.
Staff person #2 has not had a health assessment conducted within the last 24 months. The most recent documentation of a health assessment on file is dated 4/29/22.
The facilities documentation of testing the fire detection system exceeded 30 days from 11/27/23 to 12/22/23, 1/17/24 to 2/19/24, 2/19/24 to 3/21/24, and 4/17/24 to 5/20/24.
The file for child #2 lacked an initial health report within 60 days following the first day of attendance at the facility.
Staff person #2 has not had fire safety training within the last 12 months. The most recent training on file is dated 1/25/23.
The file for staff person #1 had documentation of completing the pre-service trainings Pediatric First Aid/CPR on 5/31/23 and Health and Safety on 11/6/23 but were not within 90 days of hire (See LIS Code Sheet).
The file for staff person #2 was observed to have documentation of the PA Criminal History and PA Child Abuse Clearance results that were not renewed before the expiration date of the most current certification required under CPSL. PA Criminal History: 3.26.18 and 4.14.23. PA Child Abuse: 4.2.18 and 4.26.23. The file for staff person #2 was observed to have documentation of certificate of Mandated Reporter training that was not renewed before the expiration date of the most current certification on file required under CPSL: 3.2.18 and 4.17.23. The file for staff person #2 does not have current FBI clearance results required under CPSL. The most current FBI clearance results on file is dated 3.22.18. Staff person #2 cannot work in the facility until the FBI clearance results are submitted and verified.
The files for staff persons #2, #3, #4 and #5 were observed to have emergency plan training dated more than one year apart: 1/7/22 and 4/28/23.
A handwashing sign was not posted above the bathroom toilet in the Darone building.
The waste receptacle in the bathroom inside the Darone building was observed to not have a lid to the receptacle.
The files for staff persons #1 and #5 were observed to have documentation of health assessments that were not renewed before the expiration date of the most current certification. The health assessments on file for staff #1 are dated 9.24.19 and 4.28.23. Staff person #5 has health assessments dated 9.29.20 and 1.4.23.
The facility did not conduct or have documentation on file of fire drills being conducted from 4/22/22 to 1/30/23.
The facility did not conduct or have documentation of testing the fire detection system 4/22/22 to 1/30/23.
A written plan identifying the means of transporting a child to emergency care and staffing provisions in the event of an emergency was not posted in a conspicuously location in the Darone building.
The file for Facility Person #1, a Lifeguard, did not include an initial health assessment and TB screening.
The file for Facility Person #1, a Lifeguard, who has been employed for more than 90 days, did not include documentation of Mandated Reporter Training.
The six-hour Health and Safety Basics Certificate in the files for Staff Person #1 and #8 was dated prior to September 30, 2016. Staff Persons #1 and #8 were providing care for children unsupervised during the renewal inspection.
The NSOR Certificate in the file for Staff Person #6 was dated 10/7/21, which was after the July 2020 deadline for staff hired prior to September, 2019.
The most recent emergency plan trainings in the file for Staff Person #3 exceeded 12 months between trainings: 8/30/20-1/7/22.
The seal of the childproof lock for the cabinet under the sink in the Rec Room Bathroom was loose, which made cleaning products accessible to children in care.
Observed flaking rust on the entrance/exit doors in the Apache Building. Observed broken framework at the bottoms of the doors in the Darone Building. Observed a broken ceiling tile in the restroom of the Darone Building.
Observed flaking paint on both sides of the entry/exit decks for the Apache Building.
The most recent health reports in the file for Child #3, a preschool child, exceeded 12 months between reports.
The most recent immunization records in the files for Child #1 and #3 did not contain documentation of a flu shot conducted within the past 12 months or a letter of exemption from the parent or physician.
The fire drill/fire system check log documented two times when fire system checks exceeded 30 days between checks: 12/15/21-1/20/22 and 3/15/22-4/22/22.
The initial health report in the file for Child #2 was conducted more than 60 days after the child's first day of attendance at the facility.
The pediatric first aid/CPR Certification in the file for Staff Person #2 expired on 4/19/21.
The first fire safety training in the file for Staff Person #3 was conducted on 2/8/22, which was more than one year after the staff person's first day working in child care. The most recent fire safety trainings in the files for Staff Person #5, #6 and #7 exceeded 12 months between trainings. Staff Person #5: 9/18/20-2/8/22. Staff Person #6: 9/16/20-2/8/22. Staff Person #7: 1/29/19-2/8/22.
The six-hour Health and Safety Basics certificate in the files for Staff Person #6 and #7 was conducted prior to September 30, 2016.
The first written evaluation for Staff Person #3 was conducted on 11/28/21, which was more than one year after the staff person's first day working with children.
The files for Staff Person #1, #2 and #7 did not include 12 hours of child care training for the year 12/19/20-12/19/21. Staff Person #1: 11 Hours. Staff Person #2: 0 Hours. Staff Person #7: 6 Hours.
On 4/12/22, Child Care was being provided in Harrington Hall, which has not been measured and approved as child care space for the facility.
The most recent updated health assessments in the file for Staff Person #1 exceeded 24 months between assessments.
“Core safety” marks citations about supervision and staff ratios, discipline and caregiver conduct, background checks, child protection and safe sleep, the topics our score weights most. Pennsylvania’s records don’t grade violations by severity. “Follow-up” marks a violation re-cited at a follow-up visit, counted once. How scores work.
Complaint investigations and reported incidents
Pennsylvania’s search lists complaint investigations in which the state found at least one violation (“verified complaints”). It does not say what a complaint alleged, or whether every violation relates to it. Incident investigations look into something that happened at the center; self-reported violations are ones the center reported to the state itself.
Daily rates
| Age group | Full time, per day | Part time, per day |
|---|---|---|
| Preschool (37 mos.- Entering K) | $56.25 | $56.25 |
| Young School-Age (K-3rd gr.) | $60.75 | $41.25 |
| Older School-Age (4th gr.-15 yrs.) | $60.75 | $41.25 |
The daily price the center lists in Pennsylvania’s COMPASS search for families paying privately. The state notes that rates are subject to change and programs don’t have to share them, so confirm with the center. See what daycare costs in Pennsylvania.
About this center
Common questions
Has YMCA Camp Sherwin had any serious violations?
Pennsylvania cited 9 violations since 2021 on the topics Daycare Record treats as core safety (supervision, staff ratios, discipline, background checks, child protection or safe sleep). The most recent, on Aug 10, 2026 (caregiver conduct): “Staff person #1 restrained Child #1 using their hands to restrict Child #1's movements. This was confirmed by video footage provided by the legal entity.” Pennsylvania’s records don’t grade violations by severity; each citation is listed in full above.
Have there been complaints about YMCA Camp Sherwin?
Pennsylvania lists 1 complaint investigation since 2021 in which it found at least one violation; the violations are listed above. Its search shows these “verified complaints” but not what a complaint alleged, or whether every violation relates to it.
What is YMCA Camp Sherwin’s Keystone STARS rating?
STAR 4, effective Dec 12, 2025. Keystone STARS is Pennsylvania’s quality rating program for child care, from STAR 1 to STAR 4. It measures program quality, not inspection results, so read both.
How does YMCA Camp Sherwin compare with other daycares in Erie County?
It is tied for #48 of 81 centers in Erie County by topic-weighted citations per inspection, and has more citations per inspection than 87% of Pennsylvania certified centers with enough inspection history to compare.
When was YMCA Camp Sherwin last inspected?
May 28, 2026 (renewal). The state cited at least one violation during that visit.
How much does YMCA Camp Sherwin cost?
It reported full-time daily rates of $56.25 for preschool, $60.75 for young school-age, $60.75 for older school-age in Pennsylvania’s COMPASS search. Rates can change; confirm with the center.
Who runs YMCA Camp Sherwin?
The legal entity on its Pennsylvania certificate is YMCA Of Greater Erie.
Citations are quoted from Pennsylvania Department of Human Services inspection records (Office of Child Development and Early Learning, Bureau of Certification Services), including each finding and the center’s plan of correction. Rule numbers refer mostly to 55 Pa. Code Chapter 3270, the rules for child care centers; a few cite Chapter 20, which covers every certified facility. Pennsylvania’s records don’t grade violations by severity; the “core safety” label and the score are Daycare Record’s.
To check the state’s own record, search the center’s name on COMPASS Child Care Provider Search and open its inspection history. Data refreshed Oct 16, 2026.
Comparing centers? See how to choose a daycare: 30 questions to ask and a printable checklist.
Concerned about this center? See how to report a daycare: which state line to call, what to write down and what happens next.